My kids listened to plenty of kids’ music when they were little. Some of it was genuinely great, and some of it I can still hear against my will. But Sharon and I also started playing them Elton John and Billy Joel when they were toddlers. Later we added Elvis Costello, Joni Mitchell and the Indigo Girls. I wanted to rattle the cage a little, and I figured we might as well start before they were old enough to tell me to turn that shit off.
I was eight when I found Rush’s 2112 at the Thornhill Public Library. I was there with my mom and saw the back cover with those three guys in kimonos. She got me my first library card and I took the record home. The needle dropped, that weird synthesizer started up, and my little brain was pretty much done for. I understood roughly none of the politics and all of the drama. I could feel that something huge was about to happen, and then the guitars came in and, holy shit, it did. shaelrisman.com
That’s what I mean by rattling the cage. I wanted my kids to hear something that made them put down whatever they were doing for a second and go, What the hell is that? A toddler can hear the joy in Elton’s piano without knowing a thing about what his hands are doing. A kid can get hooked on the way the Indigo Girls’ voices come together and, years later, realize they’ve been singing the harmony the whole time. And Joni can get you with the way she sings a particular word long before you’ve had the kind of breakup that makes you consider playing the whole album again at two in the morning.
I don’t read music. Billy Joel and Elton John taught me how to play piano, which is a hell of a thing to be able to say about two guys who have no idea they did it. I listened, tried to find what they were doing with my own hands, got it wrong and went back for another listen. Playing piano has carried me through my life and saved my ass more times than I can count. So when I put those records on for my kids, I was sharing something that had already done a whole lot for me.
And now, every time I catch one of them singing along to some obscure Billy Joel tune and getting every goddamn word right, I consider it a parenting win. Anybody can sing along to “Piano Man.” When your kid knows a verse you’ve occasionally had to bluff your way through onstage, you’re allowed to feel a little smug.
What I really hoped was that they’d find music they loved enough to play for somebody else. I spent hours as a kid in front of my parents’ stereo, making mixtapes and agonizing over which song should come next. There’s a bit of yourself in that. You’re handing somebody a tape and saying, Here. This is what I’ve been listening to. I want you to hear it too. shaelrisman.com
My mom let me bring home the weird record with the guys in kimonos. She couldn’t have known I’d still be writing about it decades later. I think about that now when one of my kids puts on something I’ve never heard and says, “Dad, listen to this part.”
I listen. They gave me a fair shot with Billy.






Oh SHAEL!
I had completely forgotten that whole episode in your life! Thank you for bringing it back to me❤️❤️❤️❤️